City asks judge to toss out Ellerbrook jury's verdict - KCBD NewsChannel 11 Lubbock

City asks judge to toss out Ellerbrook jury's verdict

By James Clark | email

LUBBOCK, TX (KCBD) - The fight between City Hall and city employee Martha Ellerbrook is not over.  Last week the city filed a motion to throw out a mid-October jury verdict, or grant a new trial. 

A jury found that former Deputy City Manager Tom Adams retaliated against Ellerbrook when he hired someone else to be the city's Water Programs Coordinator.  She won a jury verdict of $243,000.  Ellerbrook claims Adams was getting back at her for helping her husband sue the city.  Adams denies the charge and resigned in 2009.

In court records the city says, "Given the state of the evidence, no reasonable jury could find that Adams knew Ellerbrook assisted her husband; and therefore, no reasonable jury could find that a causal connection existed between the assistance which Ellerbrook purportedly provided to her husband and Adam's decision to hire another."

If the judge refuses to grant the city's request, then attorneys for the city would have the option to appeal the verdict the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals.

Copyright 2010 KCBD.  All rights reserved.

  • Local News on KCBD.comNewsMore>>

  • Athletes who you may not know played multiple sports

    Athletes who you may not know played multiple sports

    Tuesday, August 22 2017 6:50 AM EDT2017-08-22 10:50:59 GMT

    These athletes include hall of famers and gold medalists in sports from football and basketball to lacrosse and track. 

    These athletes include hall of famers and gold medalists in sports from football and basketball to lacrosse and track. 

  • 5-year-old boy stabbed to death at UNC, boy's father wounded

    5-year-old boy stabbed to death at UNC, boy's father wounded

    Tuesday, August 22 2017 6:10 AM EDT2017-08-22 10:10:11 GMT
    Tuesday, August 22 2017 6:26 AM EDT2017-08-22 10:26:57 GMT

    Charges are pending against Ebony Oluwasegva, 34, in connection with a Sunday morning domestic violence incident on the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill campus that resulted in the death of the boy. 

    Charges are pending against Ebony Oluwasegva, 34, in connection with a Sunday morning domestic violence incident on the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill campus that resulted in the death of the boy. 

  • Woman attacked by rabid coyote grateful for survival instinct

    Woman attacked by rabid coyote grateful for survival instinct

    Tuesday, August 22 2017 3:49 AM EDT2017-08-22 07:49:33 GMT
    Tuesday, August 22 2017 3:49 AM EDT2017-08-22 07:49:33 GMT

    The woman says the coyote attacked her 10 or 15 times, leaving her with many deep injuries.

    The woman says the coyote attacked her 10 or 15 times, leaving her with many deep injuries.

Powered by Frankly