Texas Court of Criminal Appeals will review conviction of Lufkin - KCBD NewsChannel 11 Lubbock

Texas Court of Criminal Appeals will review conviction of Lufkin serial killer

KImberly Saenz (Source; Angelina County Jail) KImberly Saenz (Source; Angelina County Jail)
HOUSTON COUNTY, TX (KTRE) -

HOUSTON COUNTY, TX (KTRE) -

The state's top criminal appeals court has agreed to review whether a former East Texas nurse was properly convicted of capital murder and sentenced to life without parole for killing five dialysis patients by injecting them with bleach.

According to the Associated Press, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals said Wednesday it will consider written arguments on whether the jury instructions at Kimberly Saenz's 2012 trial failed to require a unanimous agreement on which individuals Saenz killed at a clinic in Lufkin.

"Appellant Kimberly Saenz respectfully requests that this court grant oral argument," stated the petition for discretionary review. "Her petition raised an issue of first impression before this court, and the errors raised on appeal involved the pervasive denial of Ms. Saenz's constitutional and statutory rights. The Court of Appeals' opinion did not address the issues as thoroughly as the law requires, and oral argument is necessary for a full and fair resolution."

In the petition for discretionary review, Saenz's attorneys argued that the Angelina County District Attorney's Office sought the death penalty, despite no direct or forensics evidence proving beyond a reasonable doubt that she killed up to five of her dialysis patients and injured an additional five patients by injecting their dialysis lines with bleach."

Former Angelina County District Attorney Clyde Herrington tired the case and said Saenz's was caught red handed.

"A patient reported seeing Kim inject two other patients with bleach," Herrington said.

Herrington further explained in most murder cases the motive is quite obvious but this case was quite complex.

"She didn't have control over many areas of her life but she could control her patients. She had power of life and death over them," Herrington said.

Saenz's attorneys claimed that the state told the jurors they could convict Saenz of capital murder if they found beyond a reasonable doubt that she intentionally or knowingly caused the death of "more than one" of five alleged victims, "without unanimous agreement as to which specific victims were murdered."

Saenz's attorneys argued in the petition that a jury must unanimously agree on the identity and the number of murder victims to support the capital murder charge.

A lower appeals court upheld her conviction and sentence earlier this year.

"Additionally, the Court dismissed counsel's failure to object to the jury charge as indicative of ineffectiveness because it found the jury charge to be proper," the petition for discretionary review stated. "However, it was not just counsel's failure to object to the jury charge that exhibited representation below the professional norms. Counsel did not object to a jury charge that he believed to be improper, as evidenced by his Motion for New Trial"

In addition, Saenz's attorneys contended in the petition for discretionary review that the Fourth Court of Appeals ruled Saenz "did not receive ineffective assistance of counsel," despite the fact that it did not conduct a thorough review of the issues regarding ineffective legal representation that were brought up in the initial appeal.

The Angelina District Attorney's office said that Sanez's now has 30 days to file a brief with the Court of Criminal Appeals.  Once that appeal is in,  the Angelina County District Attorney Office then has 30 days to file a response.

The Court of Criminal Appeals ultimately could order a new trial for Saenz.

An Angelina County jury convicted Saenz, 40, of capital murder and three counts of aggravated assault on March 30, 2012. On April 2, the jury sentenced Saenz to life in prison. Because it was a capital offense, she will never be eligible for parole. The jury also handed down three 20-year prison sentences for the assault charges.

The Associated Press contributed to this story.

Copyright 2014 KTRE. All rights reserved.

  • Local News on KCBD.comNewsMore>>

  • Estimated 7,000 bodies may be buried at former asylum

    Estimated 7,000 bodies may be buried at former asylum

    Wednesday, May 23 2018 2:51 PM EDT2018-05-23 18:51:55 GMT
    Wednesday, May 23 2018 4:53 PM EDT2018-05-23 20:53:14 GMT
    (AP Photo/Rogelio V. Solis). In this May 9, 2018 photo taken in Starkville, Miss., Mississippi State University anthropologist Molly Zuckerman holds a portion of a mandible extracted from one of the graves unearthed at what was the graveyard of the Mis...(AP Photo/Rogelio V. Solis). In this May 9, 2018 photo taken in Starkville, Miss., Mississippi State University anthropologist Molly Zuckerman holds a portion of a mandible extracted from one of the graves unearthed at what was the graveyard of the Mis...
    Officials in Mississippi believe the remains of as many as 7,000 former patients at an asylum could be lying in an empty, grassy field on a university campus.
    Officials in Mississippi believe the remains of as many as 7,000 former patients at an asylum could be lying in an empty, grassy field on a university campus.
  • Pompeo: Fate of US-NKorea summit rests with Kim Jong Un

    Pompeo: Fate of US-NKorea summit rests with Kim Jong Un

    Wednesday, May 23 2018 12:44 AM EDT2018-05-23 04:44:27 GMT
    Wednesday, May 23 2018 4:52 PM EDT2018-05-23 20:52:48 GMT
    (AP Photo/Evan Vucci). President Donald Trump meets with South Korean President Moon Jae-In in the Oval Office of the White House, Tuesday, May 22, 2018, in Washington.(AP Photo/Evan Vucci). President Donald Trump meets with South Korean President Moon Jae-In in the Oval Office of the White House, Tuesday, May 22, 2018, in Washington.

    The June 12 summit, planned for Singapore, offers a historic chance for peace on the peninsula - but also the risk of an epic diplomatic failure that would allow the North to revive and advance its nuclear weapons program.

    The June 12 summit, planned for Singapore, offers a historic chance for peace on the peninsula - but also the risk of an epic diplomatic failure that would allow the North to revive and advance its nuclear weapons program.

  • Judge: President can't block critics on Twitter

    Judge: President can't block critics on Twitter

    Wednesday, May 23 2018 1:43 PM EDT2018-05-23 17:43:15 GMT
    Wednesday, May 23 2018 4:53 PM EDT2018-05-23 20:53:08 GMT
    A federal judge in New York says President Donald Trump cannot block his critics on Twitter without violating the First Amendment. (Source: CNN)A federal judge in New York says President Donald Trump cannot block his critics on Twitter without violating the First Amendment. (Source: CNN)

    A federal judge in New York says President Donald Trump cannot block his critics on Twitter without violating the First Amendment.

    A federal judge in New York says President Donald Trump cannot block his critics on Twitter without violating the First Amendment.

Powered by Frankly